An incomplete history of language facilities for concurrency

12 October 2016 1:45 PM (pl | concurrency | erlang | go | csp | guile | fibers | callback hell)

I have lately been in the market for better concurrency facilities in Guile. I want to be able to write network servers and peers that can gracefully, elegantly, and efficiently handle many tens of thousands of clients and other connections, but without blowing the complexity budget. It's a hard nut to crack.

Part of the problem is implementation, but a large part is just figuring out what to do. I have often thought that modern musicians must be crushed under the weight of recorded music history, but it turns out in our humble field that's also the case; there are as many concurrency designs as languages, just about. In this regard, what follows is an incomplete, nuanced, somewhat opinionated history of concurrency facilities in programming languages, with an eye towards what I should "buy" for the Fibers library I have been tinkering on for Guile.

* * *

Modern machines have the raw capability to serve hundreds of thousands of simultaneous long-lived connections, but it’s often hard to manage this at the software level. Fibers tries to solve this problem in a nice way. Before discussing the approach taken in Fibers, it’s worth spending some time on history to see how we got here.

One of the most dominant patterns for concurrency these days is “callbacks”, notably in the Twisted library for Python and the Node.js run-time for JavaScript. The basic observation in the callback approach to concurrency is that the efficient way to handle tens of thousands of connections at once is with low-level operating system facilities like poll or epoll. You add all of the file descriptors that you are interested in to a “poll set” and then ask the operating system which ones are readable or writable, as appropriate. Once the operating system says “yes, file descriptor 7145 is readable”, you can do something with that socket; but what? With callbacks, the answer is “call a user-supplied closure”: a callback, representing the continuation of the computation on that socket.

Building a network service with a callback-oriented concurrency system means breaking the program into little chunks that can run without blocking. Whereever a program could block, instead of just continuing the program, you register a callback. Unfortunately this requirement permeates the program, from top to bottom: you always pay the mental cost of inverting your program’s control flow by turning it into callbacks, and you always incur run-time cost of closure creation, even when the particular I/O could proceed without blocking. It’s a somewhat galling requirement, given that this contortion is required of the programmer, but could be done by the compiler. We Schemers demand better abstractions than manual, obligatory continuation-passing-style conversion.

Callback-based systems also encourage unstructured concurrency, as in practice callbacks are not the only path for data and control flow in a system: usually there is mutable global state as well. Without strong patterns and conventions, callback-based systems often exhibit bugs caused by concurrent reads and writes to global state.

Some of the problems of callbacks can be mitigated by using “promises” or other library-level abstractions; if you’re a Haskell person, you can think of this as lifting all possibly-blocking operations into a monad. If you’re not a Haskeller, that’s cool, neither am I! But if your typey spidey senses are tingling, it’s for good reason: with promises, your whole program has to be transformed to return promises-for-values instead of values anywhere it would block.

An obvious solution to the control-flow problem of callbacks is to use threads. In the most generic sense, a thread is a language feature which denotes an independent computation. Threads are created by other threads, but fork off and run independently instead of returning to their caller. In a system with threads, there is implicitly a scheduler somewhere that multiplexes the threads so that when one suspends, another can run.

In practice, the concept of threads is often conflated with a particular implementation, kernel threads. Kernel threads are very low-level abstractions that are provided by the operating system. The nice thing about kernel threads is that they can use any CPU that is the kernel knows about. That’s an important factor in today’s computing landscape, where Moore’s law seems to be giving us more cores instead of more gigahertz.

However, as a building block for a highly concurrent system, kernel threads have a few important problems.

One is that kernel threads simply aren’t designed to be allocated in huge numbers, and instead are more optimized to run in a one-per-CPU-core fashion. Their memory usage is relatively high for what should be a lightweight abstraction: some 10 kilobytes at least and often some megabytes, in the form of the thread’s stack. There are ongoing efforts to reduce this for some systems but we cannot expect wide deployment in the next 5 years, if ever. Even in the best case, a hundred thousand kernel threads will take at least a gigabyte of memory, which seems a bit excessive for book-keeping overhead.

Kernel threads can be a bit irritating to schedule, too: when one thread suspends, it’s for a reason, and it can be that user-space knows a good next thread that should run. However because kernel threads are scheduled in the kernel, it’s rarely possible for the kernel to make informed decisions. There are some “user-mode scheduling” facilities that are in development for some systems, but again only for some systems.

The other significant problem is that building non-crashy systems on top of kernel threads is hard to do, not to mention “correct” systems. It’s an embarrassing situation. For one thing, the low-level synchronization primitives that are typically provided with kernel threads, mutexes and condition variables, are not composable. Also, as with callback-oriented concurrency, one thread can silently corrupt another via unstructured mutation of shared state. It’s worse with kernel threads, though: a kernel thread can be interrupted at any point, not just at I/O. And though callback-oriented systems can theoretically operate on multiple CPUs at once, in practice they don’t. This restriction is sometimes touted as a benefit by proponents of callback-oriented systems, because in such a system, the callback invocations have a single, sequential order. With multiple CPUs, this is not the case, as multiple threads can run at the same time, in parallel.

Kernel threads can work. The Java virtual machine does at least manage to prevent low-level memory corruption and to do so with high performance, but still, even Java-based systems that aim for maximum concurrency avoid using a thread per connection because threads use too much memory.

In this context it’s no wonder that there’s a third strain of concurrency: shared-nothing message-passing systems like Erlang. Erlang isolates each thread (called processes in the Erlang world), giving each it its own heap and “mailbox”. Processes can spawn other processes, and the concurrency primitive is message-passing. A process that tries receive a message from an empty mailbox will “block”, from its perspective. In the meantime the system will run other processes. Message sends never block, oddly; instead, sending to a process with many messages pending makes it more likely that Erlang will pre-empt the sending process. It’s a strange tradeoff, but it makes sense when you realize that Erlang was designed for network transparency: the same message send/receive interface can be used to send messages to processes on remote machines as well.

No network is truly transparent, however. At the most basic level, the performance of network sends should be much slower than local sends. Whereas a message sent to a remote process has to be written out byte-by-byte over the network, there is no need to copy immutable data within the same address space. The complexity of a remote message send is O(n) in the size of the message, whereas a local immutable send is O(1). This suggests that hiding the different complexities behind one operator is the wrong thing to do. And indeed, given byte read and write operators over sockets, it’s possible to implement remote message send and receive as a process that serializes and parses messages between a channel and a byte sink or source. In this way we get cheap local channels, and network shims are under the programmer’s control. This is the approach that the Go language takes, and is the one we use in Fibers.

Structuring a concurrent program as separate threads that communicate over channels is an old idea that goes back to Tony Hoare’s work on “Communicating Sequential Processes” (CSP). CSP is an elegant tower of mathematical abstraction whose layers form a pattern language for building concurrent systems that you can still reason about. Interestingly, it does so without any concept of time at all, instead representing a thread’s behavior as a trace of instantaneous events. Threads themselves are like functions that unfold over the possible events to produce the actual event trace seen at run-time.

This view of events as instantaneous happenings extends to communication as well. In CSP, one communication between two threads is modelled as an instantaneous event, partitioning the traces of the two threads into “before” and “after” segments.

Practically speaking, this has ramifications in the Go language, which was heavily inspired by CSP. You might think that a channel is just a an asynchronous queue that blocks when writing to a full queue, or when reading from an empty queue. That’s a bit closer to the Erlang conception of how things should work, though as we mentioned, Erlang simply slows down writes to full mailboxes rather than blocking them entirely. However, that’s not what Go and other systems in the CSP family do; sending a message on a channel will block until there is a receiver available, and vice versa. The threads are said to “rendezvous” at the event.

Unbuffered channels have the interesting property that you can select between sending a message on channel a or channel b, and in the end only one message will be sent; nothing happens until there is a receiver ready to take the message. In this way messages are really owned by threads and never by the channels themselves. You can of course add buffering if you like, simply by making a thread that waits on either sends or receives on a channel, and which buffers sends and makes them available to receives. It’s also possible to add explicit support for buffered channels, as Go, core.async, and many other systems do, which can reduce the number of context switches as there is no explicit buffer thread.

Whether to buffer or not to buffer is a tricky choice. It’s possible to implement singly-buffered channels in a system like Erlang via an explicit send/acknowlege protocol, though it seems difficult to implement completely unbuffered channels. As we mentioned, it’s possible to add buffering to an unbuffered system by the introduction of explicit buffer threads. In the end though in Fibers we follow CSP’s lead so that we can implement the nice select behavior that we mentioned above.

As a final point, select is OK but is not a great language abstraction. Say you call a function and it returns some kind of asynchronous result which you then have to select on. It could return this result as a channel, and that would be fine: you can add that channel to the other channels in your select set and you are good. However, what if what the function does is receive a message on a channel, then do something with the message? In that case the function should return a channel, plus a continuation (as a closure or something). If select results in a message being received over that channel, then we call the continuation on the message. Fine. But, what if the function itself wanted to select over some channels? It could return multiple channels and continuations, but that becomes unwieldy.

What we need is an abstraction over asynchronous operations, and that is the main idea of a CSP-derived system called “Concurrent ML” (CML). Originally implemented as a library on top of Standard ML of New Jersey by John Reppy, CML provides this abstraction, which in Fibers is called an operation1. Calling send-operation on a channel returns an operation, which is just a value. Operations are like closures in a way; a closure wraps up code in its environment, which can be later called many times or not at all. Operations likewise can be performed2 many times or not at all; performing an operation is like calling a function. The interesting part is that you can compose operations via the wrap-operation and choice-operation combinators. The former lets you bundle up an operation and a continuation. The latter lets you construct an operation that chooses over a number of operations. Calling perform-operation on a choice operation will perform one and only one of the choices. Performing an operation will call its wrap-operation continuation on the resulting values.

While it’s possible to implement Concurrent ML in terms of Go’s channels and baked-in select statement, it’s more expressive to do it the other way around, as that also lets us implement other operations types besides channel send and receive, for example timeouts and condition variables.

1 CML uses the term event, but I find this to be a confusing name. In this isolated article my terminology probably looks confusing, but in the context of the library I think it can be OK. The jury is out though.

2 In CML, synchronized.

* * *

Well, that's my limited understanding of the crushing weight of history. Note that part of this article is now in the Fibers manual.

Thanks very much to Matthew Flatt, Matthias Felleisen, and Michael Sperber for pushing me towards CML. In the beginning I thought its benefits were small and complication large, but now I see it as being the reverse. Happy hacking :)

186 responses

  1. gasche says:

    The multicore-OCaml people have been asking the same sort of questions in the last few years, trying to find a reasonable compromise between generality and cost of implementation. They have a wiki page at

    One interesting thing about their current design (among many others) is that they propose to let users implement their own scheduler in (OCaml) user-space, instead of implementing a fixed scheduler in the runtime. For this they propose the addition to OCaml of "effects handlers", which could be described shortly as a structured (and typed) style for delimited control.

    Fibers is also a "user-space" implementation of concurrency as it is a Guile library, but you do not seem to emphasize the possibility of implementing domain-specific schedulers -- it is not clear by quickly looking at the code for a non-Scheme expert to see whether the design in fact bakes in a specific scheduler implementation. Is this part of your design considerations?

    (Another recent part of the multicore-OCaml work is the choice to implement a [Reagents]( library for lockfree concurrency. Reagents, introduced in [this 2012 paper by Aaron Turon](, allow composable construction of lock-free algorithms and data structure. They are more low-level than CML-style primitives (and less expressive: they remain within the subset of algorithms expressible with only atomic locking), but seem to elegantly pander to some performance-justified needs.

  2. wingo says:

    Thanks for stopping by, gasche, and thanks for the links :)

    Regarding scheduling, I don't know what to do. One of the reasons I am working on Fibers as a library is that I know I'm going to make a bunch of mistakes and I don't want to yoke Guile users (and maintainers!) to those mistakes for forever. So your question has a trivial answer in that you can just use some other threading library, or fork this one.

    However that's not very satisfactory :) I will look at what OCaml is doing for inspiration. In the beginning it will probably be a simple work-stealing implementation with no priorities.

    The reagents library looks very interesting, thanks! Incidentally in Fibers is lock-free as well, but using a naive approach -- a mixture of some data structures that can only be manipulated by particular threads, and some that are compare-and-swap over persistent data structures. CAS and GC are so nice together.

    Fibers is currently not pre-emptive. I want to change that at some point, though probably as an option -- some people won't want pre-emption I guess.

  3. Ole Laursen says:

    Have you read this book?

    It's a bit of an eye opener.

    I'll be reading up on CML, but I think you might be making a mistake here by confounding the need to handle multiple connections with concurrency. The two things should have nothing to do with each other. You should not need concurrency to talk to multiple endpoints.

    Event-based: I think some of the flak event-based systems are getting is somewhat undeserved - many network applications are event-based in nature. Like a GUI, they're waiting for something to happen. So the problem isn't as such the events, it's more the fact that the underlying system is married to the multiple-endpoints-means-multiple-threads idea so the event handler may block if it needs to do something a bit complicated (like replying) and can't be written sequentially without breaking the event loop.

    In the ideal system, I would write my network service with events where it makes sense, and the handlers for those events would then be able to reply etc. without blocking the whole application. I would not have multiple threads or any concurrency, at all times having only one handler running. Unless I really need the concurrency, e.g. for heavy computations, in which case I'd confine the concurrency to a little isolated part. Or split the load between multiple processes, each having no internal concurrency.

    I think other languages are slowly getting there through the await idea.

  4. Patrick Logan says:

    Linda / tuple spaces / JavaSpaces provides a coordination mechanism which is simple, by value, and expressively able to implement anything from CSP channels to pub/sub and more in a single process or multiple distributed processes, depending on the implementation.

    e.g. see the QIX OS use of "kernel linda"

  5. Siteforyou says:

    Yes you are right (Y) Modern machines have the raw capability to serve hundreds of thousands of simultaneous long-lived connections :) Well you can check my article too to get all the download links of Movies :) rel='external nofollow

  6. Essay Help Service says:

    Some portion of the issue is execution, yet a vast part is simply making sense of what to do. I have regularly felt that current artists must be smashed under the heaviness of recorded music history

  7. Affordable Research Paper Writing says:

    The reagents library looks exceptionally intriguing, much appreciated! By chance in Fibers is without bolt also, yet utilizing a credulous approach - a blend of a few information structures that must be controlled by specific strings.

  8. Pay Someone to Write my Research Paper says:

    Some segment of the issue is execution, yet an immeasurable part is essentially comprehending what to do. I have frequently felt that present specialists must be crushed under the weight of recorded music history

  9. Essay Writing Service says:

    The reagents library looks uncommonly interesting, quite valued! By chance in Fibers is without jolt additionally, yet using an unsophisticated approach - a mix of a couple data structures that must be controlled by particular strings.

  10. Cheap Assignment Writing Service Uk says:

    Occasion based I think some about the fire occasion based frameworks are getting is to some degree undeserved many system applications are occasion situated in nature. One reason I am taking a shot at Fibers as a library is that I know will commit a pack of errors and I would prefer not to burden Guile clients and maintainers to those missteps for until the end of time.

  11. best pellet Grills says:

    The reagents library looks uncommonly interesting, quite valued! By chanc

  12. Online Custom Dissertation Help says:

    Event based I contemplate the fire event based structures are getting is to some degree undeserved numerous framework applications are event arranged in nature. One reason I am tackling Fibers as a library is that I know will confer a pack of blunders and I would lean toward not to weight Guile customers and maintainers to those stumbles for until the finish of time

  13. Essay Editing says:

    It's additionally conceivable to include unequivocal support for cushioned channels, as Go, core.async, and numerous different frameworks do, which can decrease the quantity of setting switches as there is no express cradle string.

  14. GroovyEssays says:

    Piece strings can work. The Java virtual machine does in any event figure out how to anticipate low-level memory defilement and to do as such with superior, yet at the same time, even Java-based frameworks that go for most extreme simultaneousness abstain from utilizing a string for every association since strings utilize excessively memory.

  15. Dissertation Proposal Writing says:

    One reason I am tackling Fibers as a library is that I know will submit a pack of blunders and I would favor not to load Guile customers and maintainers to those slips for until the finish of time. The two things ought to have nothing to do with each other. You ought not require simultaneous to converse with numerous endpoints.

  16. Buy an Assignment says:

    Event based I ponder the fire event based structures are getting is to some degree undeserved numerous framework applications are event arranged in nature. One reason I am tackling Fibers as a library is that I know will submit a pack of blunders and I would lean toward not to trouble Guile customers and maintainers to those slips for until the finish of time.

  17. Click on the link says:

    Present day machines have the crude ability to serve a huge number of concurrent seemingly perpetual associations, yet it's frequently difficult to deal with this at the product level. Strands tries to take care of this issue nicy. Before talking about the approach taken in Fibers, it merits investing some energy in history to perceive how we arrived.

  18. Someone Write my Dissertation says:

    Their memory utilization is generally high for what ought to be a lightweight deliberation: approximately 10 kilobytes at any rate and regularly a few megabytes, as the string's stack. There are progressing endeavors to lessen this for a few frameworks however we can't expect wide organization in the following 5 years, if at any point. Indeed, even in the best case, a hundred thousand portion strings will take no less than a gigabyte of memory, which appears somewhat inordinate for accounting overhead.

  19. Assignment Writing Services UK says:

    There are progressing endeavors to reduce this for some frameworks however we can't expect extensive organization in the following five years, if at any point.

  20. Academic Writing Service UK says:

    Great article, I agree that it is pretty hard to find a full free resource but it is better to invest a little bit because the full features are lock in free version.

  21. Dissertation Writing Services says:

    Present day machines have the crude ability to serve countless concurrent enduring associations, however it's regularly difficult to deal with this at the product level. Filaments tries to tackle this issue nicy. Before talking about the approach taken in Fibers, it merits investing some energy in history to perceive how we arrived.

  22. Do my Dissertation says:

    the 2 matters should have nothing to do with every different. You have to no longer want concurrency to speak to a couple of endpoints. concerning scheduling, I don't know what to do. one of the motives I am operating on Fibers as a library is that I understand I am going to make a group of errors and I don't need to yoke Guile users and maintainers to the one's errors for all time.

  23. Essay Help says:

    Language develops the atmosphere of concurrency between the different communities. I do Essay Help For that student who needs a different type of help in essay writing. I also maintain the level of concurrency while writing.

  24. Dissertation help UK says:

    I have had an interest in programming for a while and I really like what I'm seeing here in terms of control and structure. My question is if RUST is a good first programing language for a beginner like myself to learn.

  25. 2v0-731 braindumps says:

    Hi, great to see your website. I like the content and the research done behind every aspect of your blog. It looks great and very knowledgeable. Keep it up the good work.

  26. how do i restart in windows 10 says:

    Indeed great story on the concurrency.

  27. IPL Tickets in Hyderabad says:

    As Expected This Time Also You Can Book SRH IPL Tickets Online Booking By Just Paying 500 Rs For Each Ticket. Please Note City by City Price Gets Decided, Sometime Price May Be lower Then How to Book Sun risers Hyderabad Tickets IPL 2018.

  28. NDA Admit card 2018 says:

    As we all know that most of the candidates are keenly showing their interest towards attending the competitive examinations. Generally, the competitive examinations are mainly available for the candidates who all are wanted to apply for the central government jobs. However, we all know that most of the candidates have recently applied for National Defence Academy and Naval Academy NDA and NA National Level Examination.

  29. Como funciona says:

    If you can, you can be sure that it will be a great achievement.

  30. App Socio says:

    I have lately been in the market for better concurrency facilities in Guile. I want to be able to write network servers and peers that can gracefully, elegantly, and efficiently handle many tens of thousands of clients and other connections, but without blowing the complexity budget. It's a hard nut to crack.

  31. Walatra Sehat Sendi says:

    Our instructors ought to take more imaginative strategies for educating our youngsters. Numerous schools in our nation still take the customary technique for instructing.

  32. essaysworld says:

    It is really useful post. I'm delighted by your text and reserch. And I agree that select is OK but is not a great language abstraction.
    Thank you.

  33. Best Essay Writers UK says:

    Exhibit day machines have the rough capacity to serve endless simultaneous continuing affiliations, anyway, it's routinely hard to manage this at the item level. Fibers try to handle this issue nicely. Before discussing the approach taken in Fibers, it justifies putting some vitality in history to see how we arrived.

  34. academic paper writing services says:

    You have shared such useful thoughts related to the history of language facilities.

  35. work related injury claim says:

    I am really glad that you have shared the authentic information regarding history. Which is really informative for us.

  36. 70-333 Exact2pass says:

    Hi, great to see your website. I like the content and the research done behind every aspect of your blog. It looks great and very knowledgeable. Keep it up the good work.

  37. Tips for write introduction says:

    Good content on writing and language related in this article.

  38. top ten nursery schools karachi says:

    Our teachers should take more inventive techniques for instructing our youths.

  39. petterson says:

    I was looking of your posts on this site page and I consider this site page is truly enlightening ! Keep setting up.

  40. Dissertation Help Now says:

    Education is a human life because that human keep is not education some is nothing educated student are you need Dissertation Help Now bye I help you.

  41. SEO Services in Bangalore and Coimbatore says:

    Without Education, it is not possible for a man to sustain..

  42. cheap assignment help from brisbane says:

    About of educational field provide for cheap assignment help from Brisbane best writers work. In this place, the writer is well qualified and king of the educational field.

  43. il genio dello streaming says:

    No matter what your favorite program on television is, there are a plenty of sites that offer free videos of songs, movies, sitcoms and even news. These could be available for a download or it could be a streaming video. You have an option of accessing, previewing, playback or download. And if you are desperate enough to own it, you can buy these for a pittance.

  44. alimentos pos treino says:

    I liked my post was integrated, I will share it in my social media. thank you

  45. Do my assignment Online says:

    Hi, I am Benjamin and I thank you for sharing such a valuable information with us.

  46. Buying an Essay Online says:

    The development of the ADA programming language paperwork a unique and, at instances, intriguing contribution to the history of pc languages. Programming languages have advanced in outstanding and modern ways.

  47. buy essay online says:

    if you want to buy essay help online get help from

  48. assignment help perth says:

    It is critical to take your destiny into your very own arms. do not allow excuses or difficulties to intrude with the development for your dissertation. you can have issues assembly the not possible standards of your chairperson, problems stepping into contact together with your chairperson, or other dynamics that can show difficult.

  49. Cheap Essay Writing Service says:

    Ah, thanks for the clarification. I was always below the impression that CCS was an "earlier" system than CSP, but i suspect only the algebraic structure of CSP was when CCS.

  50. online assignment help says:

    We have already set a high standard for assignments . We always make sure that we maintain that standard because our customer satisfaction is our main priority. We have a strict quality control unit. They scrutinize the solutions and assure us about the quality. We do not compromise with the quality. If we are not satisfied, we ask the writers to revise the assignment solutions

  51. tacobell Survey says:

    Tell the Bell is offering a $500 prize money for the lucky participants who take part in this survey.tacobell feedback

  52. top ten Montessori schools Karachi says:

    What can you say about fallacies that we may commit because of our use of language?What do you think of any language 'bias'

  53. UK Assignment Help says:

    Being an academic writer from past 5 years providing assignment help writing services to college and university students also associated with Myassignmenthelp platform. I am dedicated in providing best online academic writing services to the college students at the affordable rates.

  54. Rikrit says:

    Thanks for sharing.

  55. says:

    Thanks for sharing your Knowledge Blog. And also help Full for my Business.

  56. affordable logo design says:

    It is extremely helpful post. I'm enchanted by your content and reserch. Also, I concur that select is OK however is definitely not an incredible dialect deliberation.

  57. Online Dissertation Writers says:

    It is crucial to take your future into your very own fingers. Do now not permit excuses or problems to intervene with the development in your dissertation. You can have troubles meeting the now not viable requirements of your chairperson, problems moving into touch collectively with your chairperson or different dynamics that could display difficult.

  58. Garages in London says:

    To answer your scenarios, you really need to be able to picture these triangles and their centers. Below, is a link to an excellent site that defines each of the centers that you mention in your question.

  59. essay writing service says:

    Nice and great initiative.

  60. cheap uk writers says:

    There has been a lot of sites that really offer credible services.

  61. filmstar jackets says:

    I saved this site to my bookmarks so that I can keep me in touch with you.

  62. Kelly says:

    Hi! Prove your professor that you are a bright student with our help!

  63. camila mendes jacket says:

    Excellent information on your blog, thank you for taking the time to share with us. Amazing insight you have on this, it’s nice to find a website the details so much information about different artists.

  64. Thomas More says:

    Excellent information on your blog, thank you for taking the time to share with us. Amazing insight you have on this, it’s nice to find a website the details so much information about different artists.

    hell fest jacket online

  65. essay and dissertation writing service says:

    i am glad to see your article.It is very inforamtive.

  66. Quit 9 to 5 academy review says:

    Quit 9 to 5 Academy is a marketing course planned out so smartly so that the user will learn exactly what it takes to create effective ad campaigns and generate money consistently unlike other programs that may for some time and totally leave you in the dark later.

  67. best cannabis seed bank says:

    One of my favorites usually has lighter colored leaves and has a very ligh energetic feel. Fun to walk around after smoking it.

  68. blade runner leather coat says:

    I prefer this send. It’s fantastic to uncover anyone verbalize through your heart and as well excellent on this critical intended theme can be easily viewed.

  69. Essay Writing Service says:

    I am glad to see your article. Very informative and accurate

  70. Skootie Games says:

    Amazing article, one of my favortie topic

  71. My Mac Files says:

    I prefer this send. It’s fantastic to uncover anyone verbalize through your heart and as well excellent on this critical intended theme can be easily viewed.

  72. Buy Essay Online in $2 says:

    The development of the ADA programming language paperwork a unique and, at instances, intriguing contribution to the history of pc languages. Programming languages have advanced in outstanding and modern ways.

  73. MyMathlab Answers says:

    Great initiative.

  74. Online Class help - Pay Someone To Take My Online Class says:

    Great post.This is very unique post, Thanks for sharing.

  75. MyMathLab Answers says:

    It is an amazing post

  76. Take My Online Class says:

    I really enjoyed your blog Thanks for sharing such an informative post.

  77. Amelia Wang says:

    Thanks for cool ideas for my next article. I am a blogger. You can find my blog on Enjoy reading it!

  78. Accounting Assignment Helper says:

    Really it is a great post.
    I really love your article.

  79. says:

    We treat the evaluation process serious and don’t publish fake reviews. In our review you can learn all information about the company which you won’t find elsewhere.

  80. Caitlin Sturt says:

    Hey, Your blog is very informative. It is nice to read such high-quality content. Dissertation providers deliver quality content related to your Dissertation. We also assist in nursing dissertation help in UK.

  81. Sam Lotz says:

    The limitation with the select operation is precisely the motivation for the development of the rho calculus by Greg Meredith, which adds to the pi calculus (similar to CSP) the ability to serialize the process/operation just as you describe. Check out:

    Glad to hear you had this insight and it is in Guile, I've been on the fence about investing in Guile as a platform and this might tip me over. :)

  82. managing a successful business project says:

    We will provide you with the best quality of project help by academic experts and professional project help writers who have higher education in engineering. We care about students and their future, thus we provide them "A+" grade writing to have better marks in the report card.

  83. tìm hiểu thêm says:

    Ik vindt het een beetje onzinnig om een discussie te gaan voeren over het kunnen starten en stoppen van een doorlopende reisverzekering bij vertrek en thuiskomst. Dit bestaat namelijk al en heet een tijdelijke reisverzekering :). Als het je alleen maar om de kosten gaat moet je bij jezelf nagaan hoeveel dagen je gemiddeld per jaar op vakantie gaat. Je kunt dan vrij eenvoudig bepalen of een doorlopende verzekering uit kan. Het maken van afspraken met andere partijen om een verzekering aan en/of uit te kunnen zetten is op de langere termijn alleen maar kostenverhogend en geeft wat mij betreft geen toegevoegde waarde aan het product.

  84. Source says:

    The Time Is Running Out! Think About These 5 Ways To Change Your Adtrics Academy

  85. Launching an ecommerce website says:

    It is imperative for them to take a look at the inspiration of the issue to clear all their standards and to attain nicely. I realize I shouldn't be so into this, however someway, I have nothing but religion. This has been one of these massive parts of growing up for me, and it never definitely felt over.

  86. sport bikes for sale says:

    Thanks for briefly describing the article and the information in it was really good, It helped me a lot.

  87. online class completion service says:

    When the study participants were followed up over the next five years or so, each MET they achieved during the exercise test was associated with a 9 percent lower risk of cardiovascular death, a 9 percent lower risk of cancer death and 4 percent lower risk of other causes of death, the European Society of Cardiology noted.

    In people with poor functional capacity, the death rate from heart disease was almost three times higher and cancer deaths were almost double compared to participants who had good exercise capacity.

  88. acct 324 final exam says:

    A national study by Georgetown University Health Policy Institute pointed to a correlation between this decline and an increase in the number of uninsured children.

    "We know that what has driven the trends in lower uninsured rates (prior) to 2017 is higher participation in Medicaid and CHIP," Edwin Park, co-author of the study, said Thursday in a phone interview.

    Park noted, "What we are concerned about is that a substantial reduction in Medicaid and CHIP likely means that many of these kids are going to end up uninsured."

  89. homestay says:

    Thank You

  90. hotel di jakarta says:

    Awesome posting!

  91. Java assignment help says:

    ABC Assignment Help is regarded as the proficient assignment help by thousands of assignment help seekers. Our highly experienced academic writers pen down impressive assignment solutions by undertaking a long process of research in every subject. With a decade of experience we make continuous efforts to deliver best online writing services.

  92. edubirdie reviews says:

    Looking for the best writing service online but lost in the number of fake reviews and don’t know who to believe? We at ScamFighter publish only genuine reviews on all writing service from the web. Look at the last review on:

  93. Blade runner 2049 coat says:

    Enjoyed reading the article above , really explains everything in detail,the article is very interesting and effective.Thank you and good luck for the upcoming articles

  94. assignment writers australia says:

    My Assignment Services is your first and last destination for every query you have related to ‘assignment help’ because we guarantee you the cheapest possible price of Assignment Writers Australia with the unmatched quality of assignments in Australia.

  95. Informative Speech Essays says:

    Our Pay for informative speech essays online customer access our dissertation services knowing that they are assured of the best quality essay lest they get their money back.

  96. Nursing Papers Made Easy says:

    All our Nursing Papers Made Easy that we provide to the client are assessed for high quality and any other issues that could affect the client’s grade.

  97. Emma Brown says:

    Pondering who can assist you with your homework? Too many promises to deliver a quality paper, but all they seem to be a total lie? At EssayTopicsMasters we uncover scam writing services and warn you about them. Take a look at our last Review, it might be interesting to you.

  98. uk essay writing says:

    Very Nice Blog. Awesome. I am Speechless. Thank You So Much.

  99. Write My Essay says:

    People are interacting helping others, building one of the best community.

  100. Place beyond the pines jacket says:

    Usually I never comment on blogs but your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to say something about it. You’re doing a great job Man,Keep Working.

  101. tile installer says:

    Your blog is very informative and great. Its very great read for me because your writing skills is so good and you will write this post in very good manner. Thanks!

  102. Homepage says:

    9 Seo Tips Mistakes That Will Cost You $1m Over The Next 10 Years

  103. patrick tirkey says:

    Download and install Vidmate App which is the best HD video downloader software available for Android. Get free latest HD movies, songs, and your favorite TV shows.

  104. whitbread review says:

    Whether you’re planning to explore all opportunities, consider the job you really wanted in the first place, or just move up the career ladder, we may provide you "whitbread review" on to help you make the best choice.

  105. Academic Writing Services says:

    Thanks for such an incredible article. Undoubtedly, this article is completely based on the colossal research, and right choosing of content.
    Keep it up!!

  106. skilled writing says:

    Event based I ponder the fire event based structures are getting is somewhat undeserved numerous framework applications are event arranged in nature. One reason I am accepting a taken shots at Fibers as a library is that I realize will submit a pack of mistakes and I would incline toward not to trouble Guile customers and maintainers to those slips up for until the part of the arrangement. Skilled Writing

  107. British Career Group says:

    best ielts classes in mohali
    If you are in search of best IELTS classes in Mohali then you will find one in this blog, read on. The success of our students speaks for itself that we are the best IELTS training Centre in Mohali. Our result and success rate have built up our reputation of the benchmark in the industry. There are two kinds of main IELTS test. 1) Academic test 2) General training test. Depending upon your purpose of visa and level of study one has to choose any one of it. But, due to lack of proper guidance one often gets confused. Where our executive helps to determine the goal and choose the right one.

  108. famous jackets says:

    As far as the transaction for the buying process is concerned, we try to make it as transparent to our valued customers as possible because unlike other we think of YOU as a family member and go very far to make it a hassle free business not only for you but ourselves as well.

  109. Quotes Ever says:

    I believe that imagination is stronger than knowledge. That myth is more potent than history. That dreams are more powerful than facts. That hope always triumphs over experience. That laughter is the only cure for grief. And I believe that love is stronger than death. — Robert Fulghum

  110. Source says:

    Nd10x Review Like A Pro With The Help Of These 6 Tips

  111. Website Design Company India says:

    I really support this thought of language facility for currency.
    Nice story..Great Infinitive.

  112. mobile app development agency says:

    Nice post. This story is really an impressive and constructive. I do respect your thought.
    Thank you very much

  113. lady gynecologist in kolkata says:

    Fantastic post. I really like this post.

  114. best nasal Sinus surgeon in kolkata says:

    Wonderful post.

  115. Alexa Mia says:

    With time running out and with resources falling short, students should make the decisive decision of choosing the Cheap Essay Writing Service, which is Academic Writing Experts. This service has amassed itself such a reputation, as they consistently benchmark excellent standards and are wholly professional. Thus, place an order today!

  116. Henry Jones says:

    Oh ! A good way of sharing the knowledge.. really incomplete history is always awesome. ! assignment writing help

  117. Mobile app development company in mumbai says:

    Thanks you so much for your efforts blog, If your are looking for a creative mobile app development in mumbai, Appslure provides one of the best and professional app development company in mumbai.

  118. Best essay help online UK says:

    Occasion based fire occasion structures are getting is somewhat undeserved various system applications are occasion orchestrated in nature. One explanation I am handling Fibers as a library is that I realize will give a pack of goofs and I would lean toward not to weight Guile clients and maintainers to those falters for until the completion of time.

  119. Royal UK Essay Writers says:

    Great post. Royal UK Essay Writers help students in their academic writing service form past many years. The number of students we have helped is innumerable in the UK but also in all around the world. Royal UK Essay Writers provides services assignments, Essay, thesis and help in scientific work. Royal UK Essay Writers provide the highest quality services in writing, assignments, Essay, thesis, as well as provide writing assignments, Essay, thesis in lowest price.

  120. How to write a college research paper says:

    Find the best topics for research.

  121. Dissertation Help Near Me says:

    .... In complete story .... Although it is highly recommended to use student facilities such as stadiums and quadruples, but Aggie .... has a strange history, uses some derogatory language and promotes liberal politics. agenda

  122. myassignmenthelp says:

    At Assignment studio we have a number of service’s that we have to offer, among them MyAssignmenthelp is one of the most in demand service that majority of the students inquire about. Myassignmenthelp offered by assignment studio is considered to be one of the best assignment help service offered online by a team of professional and experienced academic writers.

  123. pay to do my class says:


    thanks for sharing great post keep up the good work keep writing great stuff

  124. mymathlab answers says:

    getting academic writing help was never this easy but now you can help online class help is so easy

  125. sewa mobil jakarta says:

    Nice article, thanks for the information.

  126. web design company Dubai says:

    Every day I follow your website on a regular basis. I am really very convinced to comment on your website. I will be highly honored if you allow me to share something for everyone.

  127. digital marketing agency in Dubai says:

    This is the most innovative post I have ever seen in my life. Please keep doing these type of post.

  128. Genuine Nursing Research Papers says:

    Do you require Genuine Nursing Research Papers from a trusted Nursing Research Papers Writing Service and Reliable Nursing Assignment Help firm which guarantees high-quality Papers for the client?

  129. eilla jones says:

    wow very nice, this is an amazing blog and thanks for sharing such a good post.

  130. UK Essay Writing says:

    Nicely put. I agree with the fact that none of the networks are safe for the information transfer. Even the students who look for UK essay writing also are concerned with the safety issues.

  131. eilla jones says:

    It is so nice articles among flood of information on the internet. Thanks for the idea.

  132. Get Custom Boxes Wholesale says:

    So nice to hearing from you.

  133. Urdu news says:

    Thanks you so much for your efforts blog, If your are looking for a creative mobile app development in mumbai, Appslure provides one of the best and professional app development company in mumbai.

  134. business essay writing UK says:

    Thanks a lot for a powerful and an interesting post.

  135. Zack Rosenfeld says:

    Hey, thanks for sharing. By the way, I wanna use this professional writing service to write my essay for me online should I order some papers there guys? Write me back pls.

  136. G-SOL says:

    Thanks for sharing this blog with us. I got a wonderful idea from your blog.
    ielts coaching classes chandigarh
    G-Sol Institute is the premier Institute of IELTS training in Chandigarh catering to all your learning requisites and acts as a preparative for success in IELTS. Our simple yet methodical training system is suitable to meet the needs of students who aspire to excel in every aspect of their careers. If you are one of those insightful IELTS aspirants who like to take their preparation seriously by investing a fair amount of time in looking out for the best professional coaching centre nearby you, then this is the right place you’ve arrived at.
    Website link:-
    Email –

  137. Assignment Helps says:

    Event based I ponder the fire event based structures are getting is somewhat undeserved numerous framework applications are event arranged in nature. One explanation I am accepting a took shots at Fibers as a library is that I realize will submit a pack of mistakes and I would incline toward not to trouble Guile customers and maintainers to those slips up for until the finish of time. helps

  138. Hot Dog Boxes says:

    Thanks for sharing this article, Hot dog boxes are mostly customized in cardboard or kraft material with color printing and logo printing as per to the demand.custom cigarette boxesEmpty Cigarette BoxesCigarette boxesPre Roll PackagingCustom Cannabis Boxesmedical marijuana card Sarasotacustom burger boxescustom pie boxescustom cereal boxfrench fries boxes

  139. Web Designer Abu Dhabi says:

    Developing a web host with a callback-oriented competitiveness system ensures smashing the program into smaller pieces that can run without being removed.

  140. walmart near me says:

    I hope that there will be miracles, heal the broken heart is crying and sad. The sky is still divided night light right then we broke up already, so our love circle is like that.

  141. Spss Help says:

    Much gratitude to you such an extraordinary sum for granting to us such a captivating post. keep doing a mind boggling work.spss help

  142. Research proposals says:

    Incredible site, I will stop by more regularly to peruse your posts. research proposals

  143. Movie Blue Valentine Ryan Gosling Jacket says:

    I’m not going to lie, I was shocked by how much I really loved the collection. A lot of it really is office wear for people who hate boring clothes. I’m sad I didn’t pre order. Give respect where it’s due.

  144. Ralph Fennec says:

    Hey! I am Ralph fennec, i am running a company named Fennec Safety, Our basic aim is to provide the CRM Training and security consultation to the people, they can build the leading ability through the CRM Training and many more things. For any other update and information you can connect through my website.

  145. Assignment Help says:

    You need to realize the significance of assignment help service given by expert writers, and here we are revealing some key points which escort you to get advantage from New assignment help services.

  146. Helsinki Hammam says:

    What is Helsinki Hammam?
    Want to help us build the first Hammam of Finland? Join the ride for building the hottest urban oasis of Helsinki.
    Helsinki Hammam will be the first hammam of Finland, a traditional Middle Eastern sauna with an urban Nordic twist. We will soon open a crowdfunding campaign on . The raised funds will help us get started with the construction and our goal is to open in Autumn of 2020. Please support us in building the coolest urban oasis of Helsinki!

  147. Sarah says:

    This write up is perfect. If you guys want to draft your assignment very perfectly and seeking dissertation assignment help service then you must hire online essay writer from SourceEssay.

  148. my crm system says:

    The website is looking bit flashy and it catches the visitors eyes. Design is pretty simple and a good user friendly interface my crm system

  149. my crm system says:

    I am astoundingly astonished with your knowledge. I feel significantly trusted in sharing supportive information. I similarly need to bestow extraordinary information to various people. my crm system

  150. marketing homework help says:

    Instantly receive the best marketing homework help from our company administration for your better help we know students have very little time to write a marketing assignment don't stress and use your expensive time to your own.

  151. accounting with homework help says:

    I'm very glad to visit through such a good blog. Thanks for sharing this wonderful experience of yours with us. I hope to see you on another blog.

  152. COB CAMERA says:

  153. COB CAMERA says:

  154. alpha assignment help says:

    I enjoy kinds very own post. It will be respectable to get a single narrative inside and outside of the core of this distinctive core specialized niche will likely be commonly knowledgeable.Thesis Statement Templatethesis examplethesis examplesthesis creatorthesis makerAcdemic Assignment HelpAssignment help serviceCheap Assignment writing service

  155. online essay writer says:

    God bless you for writing this fantabulous blog. Unable to get out of the workload of your assignments and seeking online essay help then you can hire essay writers from SourceEssay.

  156. Dissertation Proofreading Services says:

    Thanks for providing the best help in writing the best help in the essay writing and proofreading.

  157. multiple regression analysis says:

    Influencing! Such a pulling in and obliging post this is. I super love it. It's so overpowering everything mulled over affecting. I am on a constantly central level mixed. multiple-regression-analysis

  158. Essay Writer says:

    Oh my god. Please share more well-founded information on the website. If you students want to submit the excellent quality assignment and want dissertation assignment help service then hire dissertation essay writers.

  159. Assignment says:

    this is the basic element that is amazingly handle in this section- i appreciate because it would be helpful for students.

  160. BM Craft says:

    Thank you

  161. whatsapp group 18+ 2020 says:

    amazing and nice

  162. human resources management case study help UK says:

    Once you understand the human resources management, it will be said to complete the different case studies related to it. In case you are looking for assistance in human resources management case study due to multiple assignments overloaded with a tight deadline then you can simply reach out to us at best assignment experts and get your work with 100% authenticity.

  163. Vivo Mobiles says:

    You can access all the Vivo mobiles phone specifications, along with their prices applicable in all the major cities

  164. Tamil Boy Baby Names says:

    Great Information sharing .. I am very happy to read this article .. thanks for giving us go through info. Fantastic nice. I appreciate this post.

  165. Best Pads says:

    Nice blog. Found while searching through

  166. Whatsapp says:

    I have a comparable intrigue this is my page read everything deliberately and let me comprehend what you think.

  167. Doraha says:

    I enjoy your writing style really enjoying this web site.

  168. says:

    interesting post. Great things you've always shared with us. Thanks for sharing. keep posting.

  169. newassignmenthelp australia says:

    Get the best assignment help brisbane from brisbane by experts at affordable prices. Get best assignment writing services by professional assignment writers of Brisbane. On-Time Delivery. A+ Quality.

  170. newassignmenthelp australia says:

    Get the best assignment help wollongong from wollongong by experts at affordable prices. Get best assignment writing services by professional assignment writers of Wollongong. On-Time Delivery. A+ Quality.

  171. famous urdu novels says:

    Thank you for sharing this fascinating information together.

  172. zahra says:

    thanks for sharing

  173. Rickey says:

    I have been a keen follower of your website.recently I came across this topic and after reading the whole article ,I am amazed that how well you have written it.Amazing writing skills shown.You have done a good research on this topic.Great Work. if some one is looking for apkgames | andorid apps please visit us.

  174. Amy C. Martinez says:

    At Impexlog Inc. we have a plethora of the best products for all ages which are available for you at affordable prices. Whether you are looking for home décor products or clothes for men, we have all that you need. Make sure to visit our website for more details

  175. newassignmenthelp australia says:

    Get the best marketing assignment help from Australia by experts at affordable prices. Get best marketing assignment writing services by professional assignment writers of Australia. On-Time Delivery. A+ Quality.

  176. James says:

    This is such an interesting blog, thank you for writing it.

    We move

  177. Pakistan Talk shows says:

    Hi! I am human. Welcome to News / Media by Get Tips on Blogging and SEO to build your own profitable blog.

  178. Tecno Mobile Prices says:

    This is such an interesting blog, we are get informative information today thanks for sharing and keep posting.

  179. saorenmax01 says:

  180. Black Leather Jackets says:

    Interesting post! Thank you for sharing them! I hope you will continue to have similar posts to share with everyone.

  181. Samish Leather says:

    Samish leather is an online store where you can Buy Tv Series Jackets with various designs and many other stuff. We are providing it on very attractive prices.

  182. Academic Writing Services says:

    Language facilities uncompleted story is quite interesting.I have read it. This post is interesting. you have not included the stuff of words. Thanks for sharing it.

  183. garage removals Manchester says:

    Language is the key to communication, it helps customers do more business in a natural manner.

  184. shed removals Blackpool says:

    Welcome to My House Clearance Blackpool; we specialise in house clearances and rubbish removal throughout Blackpool and the surrounding areas. Domestic and commercial premises, we cover both. We offer a quick, straightforward and professional solution for all of your clearance needs and offer a cost-efficient alternative to hiring a skip. So whether you require booking a clearance or removal for a particular future date or you are seeking an immediate same-day job carrying out, our clearance company in Blackpool will do our upmost to accommodate. Contact us today to discuss your requirements.

  185. Dig says:

    Keep up the fantastic work!

  186. tenant clearances Halifax says:

    Concurrency has been used for more business online, it dan replace actual money changing.

Leave a Reply